Club

04 Nov DA Part 3

First you need to read part 1 and 2... My motivation in writing these articles is mostly to organized my own thoughts and opinions, but I also feel there is too much good advice given to the wrong people, which is bad.  I know I have some bias here as a high school and college coach, but I am trying to be objective. Recently I read this article. (See below for my rebuttal) It was informative, but I think it needs to be explored further, specifically I will comment on the questions related to Development Academy's. Here are some takeaways for those who wont do the detailed reading.
  • The best advice form the article, "If your daughter is happy now, continue to find a solution where she’s happy." No body HAS to play soccer, if it's not fun, you are doing it wrong.
  • This is super important to remember DA is NATIONAL TEAM focused. All of April's advice will have a bias like mine, only her advice is for the 1% ... If DA's are for the national team but US soccer will continue to scout ECNL, ODP and other national events, why give up everything else to play DA?
  • My opinion here is this... If you are not on the national team radar by U15 IT. AIN'T. HAPPENING. and there is no reason to join a DA.
  • 74 X 20 players per team 1,480 DA players. There are approximately 325 D1 schools. Not every DA player is going D1, so what advantage do they have?
  • DA's are one option for college-bound players, however a great many clubs can produce college-bound players! This is the bad advice I was referring to earlier, unfortunately many parents will read this a blindly follow April's comments even when a DA is not the right fit.
  • Colleges don't care! If you can play I don't care where you learned how. In fact, some times the bigger the club or league the player comes from, the bigger the "head" the player comes with. I have heard coaches lament ECNL players because they think they are too good for their college team, I can only imagine what the will think of DA players.
  • When it comes to scholarships bottom line is most important.  A $25k scholarship to a $50k school is still $25k out of pocket.  A $1k scholarship to a $15k school is only $14k out of pocket.
  • What good does it do a player to play DA/D1 bound and be miserable?  Keep in mind just because it's D1 doesn't mean it's the right place to go to school and get an education. Southern Utah University is D1, but living in rural Ceder City may not be a great fit for you.
  • Even if DA's "allow" girls to play HS, you know they will not like it. DA's have a 10 month season which starts in August and runs through May. High school and DA run at the same time. If you break for HS and come back to the DA you only play 6-7 months for the DA? Be very skeptical of this. Sounds to good to be true. Stick to what you know. If you play DA you will not play HS.
  • Dugh, club is the best place for development who wouldn't agree with that? That doesn't mean DA! Also, we (HS coaches) do our very best to focus on development but how much development can they get in 3.5 months? I agree HS is more social, but I know I always try and focus on development, granted some schools do a better job than others, but I despise the broad brush they use for HS sports. I also take issue with the "bad habits" comment. This is a classic line clubs and US soccer use to confuse and discourage players from playing. This could be the case at some schools, but that broad brush can't stay in the lines again. 
  • I don't think anyone is arguing that kids shouldn't play club. As a HS coach I want them playing club, it's when club says, "don't play high school" that I take issue. It's not ONE OR THE OTHER it's BOTH and successfully managing them for 99% of the population. But much of April's advice is really for the 1%.
  • The lines between DA's and club are being blurred and they should not be. DA's are for national team.
Here is the plan the vast majority of kids playing soccer should follow.
  1. Find a Good club, one that focuses on development and makes you happy.
  2. Play High School, one that is well organized, fun, and recognizes your hard work.
  3. Tryout for ODP. This is your National Team option. If you don't make it, then no, it's not happening.
  4. If college through all this a college finds your fancy, play. If not use it for what's there for, an education. Athletic scholarships should ALWAYS be Plan B.
Read More
Disney awards

08 Jun What’s your fit?

10 years ago, I began coaching soccer. It all began when I felt the urge to be involved in competitive soccer again, but my playing days were over so I was going to have to be a coach. I was hungry to prove myself, I wanted to do a good job and be successful. My first job was a girls JV coach at McKeel Academy. I devoted dozens of hours to being the best that I could. Every day we had practice and I poured my heart and sole into it. We finished 11-3 and I fell in love with coaching, cried my eyes out at the banquet and was totally, completely hooked. But, I noticed JV soccer was not as respected as the varsity team.
Read More
IMG951133

04 Jun Development Academy’s Part 1

There is so much to say about this that I am not sure I can fit this into one post... so I am calling this part 1. Also, I am admitting to being totally biased here, I am going to come right out and say that I do not support development academy's. I fundamentally disagree with their premise, something I plan to explain in detail over the course of these blog posts.
Read More

12 Dec Who Plays? Part 1

These are by far the toughest decisions I make as coach; who starts, who plays, for how long and where. In high school soccer, I coach the highest and most competitive level 90% of American kids will play. As such playing time is not going to be divided up evenly, nor does it have to be according to Dr. Nicole Lavoi, Associate Director of the Tucker Center for Research on Girls and Women in Sports However... Every week, every game the starting 11 is up for grabs. If you want to start, get lots of playing time and play the position you want, you better meet three criteria to even be considered. First, physically show up to practice. If you don't come to practice, even for a good reasons, you miss the lessons on how I want you to play as a team, therefore you may not play. Second, when you show up, be there mentally also, with the right attitude. If you are physically there but mentally somewhere else, it shows in how you practice. It is painful to watch a group of players "practice" who aren't really practicing. Third, be a skillful player. Even if you attend everything and are mentally fully engaged you must be more skillful than the other players who have met the same criteria.
Read More

16 Sep Parents, Soccer and Chess.

A few weeks ago. A parent got angry with me. They didn't like the position I was playing their child on the field. They thought he was a great forward, and perhaps he is, but I thought he was a better defender. Perhaps most importantly, a defender was what the TEAM needed. Here is a great article I wanted to share. I hope you will take the time to read it, because it is really good. I have copied the article below for those too lazy to use the link. Thanks to my assistant coach who sent me the link.   "I had a parent email me last week seeking advice for how to help her 10 year old son deal with the fact that the coach is playing him as a defender, whereas he’s usually played as a forward. It wasn’t clear to me from her email if the issue was hers or her son’s, so I (hopefully subtly) encouraged her to figure that out first. I then tried to get the point across to the parent that BEING A TEAMMATE is being a member of a team and doing what is needed – being on the bench, being the goalkeeper, being the goal scorer, being the defender that stops the other team from scoring, or the weak sided midfielder that runs up and down the field all day and rarely receives the ball. You get my point. Being on a team means you do what the team needs from you at that moment. Being a teammate means you play your heart out in whatever position you happen to be assigned. Just like a chess match, each position is essential to the proper performance of the team. I get this. Or at least I thought I did.
Read More

06 Sep Well Said…

“The way the game is educated, told, driven, we are still far away from real soccer nations,” Klinsmann told the Post. “The biggest educational problem is people think it's a coaches' game in the United States. It's not. It's a players' game.   “There's too much emphasis on telling people what to do.”
Read More